The Referendum: Yes Or No To AV?

On Thursday, the UK will vote in our first referendum since the seventies. We will get to decide whether we switch our electoral system from first past the post to the alternative vote method.

First Past The Post

Our current system is very simple. People vote for one candidate, and whichever candidate gets the most votes overall wins. There is no minimum number or percentage of votes required to win, so it is perfectly possible (and indeed, very common) to win with less than a majority of votes.

Alternative Vote

‘AV’ is the challenger. Under this voting method, voters rank the candidates in order of preference. You can rank all the candidates, or only some. If you only want one of the candidates to win, you rank that person number one and do not rank their rivals. When the votes are counted, everyone’s first preference votes are counted initially. If one candidate wins more than half of all votes, that’s it, they win. If no-one does, the lowest vote getter is eliminated. The ballots of those who voted for that person as their first preference are examined and their second preference votes are distributed.

If, after this, there is still no candidate who has won more than 50% of the vote, the next lowest vote winner is eliminated and their second preference votes distributed, and so on until someone gets 50%.

Polling Station, by hugovk

So what are the arguments? The BBC has asked the campaigns to put forward the 5 best arguments to support their view. To my mind, here are the strongest from each side:

Against AV

  • It will cost millions of pounds to implement
  • It may lead to politicians being driven to the middle to appeal to as many people as possible

In Favour of AV

  • It means politicians will have to do what the majority of the country wants if they want to be re-elected
  • Victorious candidates are likely to be those on which most constituents can agree
  • If you would be happy with one of several candidates being elected, you don’t have to choose, which may reduce tactical voting.

What has annoyed me the most about this campaign is the assertion that AV is ‘complicated’. More complicated than First Past The Post, to be sure, but all the voter really needs to know is that instead of putting a cross in the box next to your favoured candidate’s name, you put numbers to rank them in order. The most irritating thing is that ‘complicated’ is really a polite way of saying ‘You’re too stupid to understand this.’

I’m voting yes, although it looks like the no campaign will win.

What about you? Have you made up your mind? If not, here are some useful links:

No2AV campaign website: http://www.no2av.org/

Yes to Fair Votes campaign: http://www.yestofairervotes.org/content/

The Electoral Commission’s unbiased booklet explaining how both systems work: http://www.aboutmyvote.co.uk/PDF/England-accessible.pdf

Polling stations are open across the country tomorrow (5th May) from 7am to 10pm.

Advertisements

About elentari86

Apparently blogs need to cover a certain niche in order to attract readers. My aim is not to attract readers. I don't deny it would be nice not to just be spouting to myself, but the reason I set this blog up was to give myself somewhere to write down my thoughts. If anyone reads them, that's a bonus. This blog will cover a mix of things - anything that comes to mind that I want to write about. I make no promises about how often I will publish new content.
This entry was posted in Current Affairs, Politics and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s